Thursday, May 17, 2007

And So It Begins

Well, I've seen some nice purple martin action so far. That's a male and female above. I can never see and hear enough of these large swallows. They have such a musical song--most swallows have a more click-ish type sound--like little dolphins. Purple martins sing it loud and sing it proud.

I did a demo of birdJam outside. We got into the who ethics of calling in birds. When to do it, if you are going to do it, do it responsibly, etc. As we got into some of the controversy, I referenced an infamous story about a pygmy nuthatch. Years ago before I moved to Minnesota, a pygmy nuthatch was reported along the Red River in North Dakota. Just a short trip across the Red River puts you in Minnesota. The nuthatch was at a feeding station on the North Dakota side and someone played a tape and it flew over to the Minnesota side--and was a first state record...or was it? The jaunt across the river was minimal and the bird probably would have flown over of its own accord (if it hadn't already). It caused a huge rift in the birding community and accusations and arguments exploded all over. What is "artificial means of attraction" when it come to birds anyway? Technically, a feeding station is artificial attraction. The distance the bird flew was only a few hundred feet--was it really that big of deal? It wasn't nesting, it wasn't on territory--what did it matter?

Anyway, this story has reverberated throughout the birding community. I had heard of it, but never knew the parties involved. Last year at the Rio Grande Valley Bird Fest, Jeff Gordon referenced it during his program "The Top Ten Birding Moments of the last 100 Years". Well, as we were discussing it, a man laughed, raised his hand, and said, "That was me!"

Ah, connections.

And now I leave you with a male tree swallow. I must go to bed, I have to get up at 4:30am for my field trip. I'm so excited, the Country Inn and Suites in Detroit Lakes (where I am staying) is going to have breakfast and coffee going by 4:30am--sustenance--Whoot!

Labels: , ,

9 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Interesting. Did you come to any conclusion about the ethics of it, or just discussions and pros and cons? I'm curious to know.

Love the martins!

--Susan

5/18/2007 8:10 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Rosie O'Donnell has birds nesting at her front porch and needs help identifying them. She has photos posted in one of her movies at rosie.com. Any help?

Heather
Wayne, PA

5/18/2007 4:11 PM  
Anonymous Dave Hardin said...

For Heather:

None of the photos of the bird on Rosie's site are lit well enough for me to be sure, but I think they may be House Finches. I think I can see enough of the bird in one photo about halfway through, with streaking on the breast and lots of browns and whites, to think it's a House Finch.

Maybe some of the GOOD birders out there can do better. :)

Dave
Newton, NC

5/18/2007 6:26 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Sharon, most discussions of taping birds has more to do with breeding birds rather than a bird like the Pygmy Nuthatch that was out of range in North Dakota. The use of taping the P. Nuthatch to fly into Minnesota was a listing debate not a bird taping debate or better yet the topic was should the MOU counted this on it's official state list?

I bought Birdjam the other day and I am going to be advertising it on my website.

Maybe the reason David Sibley is not on your field trips is because his lap still hurts from the Cape May visit.

MH

5/18/2007 6:44 PM  
Blogger HellZiggy said...

Of course the bird would have flown over eventually! I've lived in both North Dakota and Minnesota and given the choice I would fly to the Minnesota side too!

5/18/2007 6:47 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Lol, for birdwatching to be poltical. Acourse then so are churches. You know get two people together and they will argue over anything even the color of the sky. Which I have done. I was wondering what is the best cleaner to use to get bird poop out of stuff ?
kitmarlowescot2

5/19/2007 12:51 AM  
Blogger The Rowe Family said...

Hi! I was looking at your digiscoping equipment. Is there any other options for amateurs who don't want to make a hugh investment in the spotting scope for there first try?

5/20/2007 7:08 AM  
Blogger birdchick said...

We just discussed ethics of when to call in birds if at all. Some people do it, some people don't.

Good grief, birder's even want to debate the debate of the infamous pygmy nuthatch.

I have never sat on David Sibley's lap. I have, however, sat on Don Kroodma's lap.

Rosie O'Donnell's bird is a house finch--Dave called it.

5/20/2007 8:23 PM  
Blogger birdchick said...

Hey Rowe Family -

A short generalized note on digiscoping:

The better optics you have--the better photos you will have. If you just want some equipment to document birds for your personal enjoyment, you can get some good scopes at around $300 - $400.

If you want to take crisp sharp images that could be print quality, then you will need really a good spotting scope.

Get the best spotting scope you can afford.

5/21/2007 8:25 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home

starboard
starboard
starboard
starboard