
There's a new bird seed coming onto the bird feeding market called golden safflower. Note the color in the photo above that give the seed it's name,
safflower is normally pure white. This new version claims to be higher in oil content, higher in protein and higher in fat, making it more desirable to feeder birds. It's also supposed to be non germinating and I'm not sure if that's because it's out hull-less or if it's been roasted.

The big advantage to safflower in the past has been that cardinals, chickadees, nuthatches (above), mourning doves, rose-breasted grosbeaks, and house finches really enjoy the seed but grackles and house sparrows do not care for the taste and
usually leave it alone. That's not to say that house sparrows won't eat when desperate. Starlings are physically unable to eat it, since they do not have bills that are strong enough to open seeds in a hard shell.

But what about golden safflower--will it now be tastier to house sparrows and grackles? We'll have to wait and see. I first noticed the safflower at
Carpenter Nature Center, on of their 20 some odd bird feeders was filled with it and a flock of chickadees preferred it over any other. And went on a search for it. I've found two bird stores in the Twin Cities that carry it (I didn't call all of them) and I'm sure other birds stores will follow suit soon (at the least the good ones will).

I've been testing it out at
Mr. Neil's feeding stations and the birds took to it right away--especially the nuthatches and the chickadees. the birds still prefer nuts and sunflower but there is certainly more activity at the golden safflower than at the regular safflower. I tried it at home and the house sparrows just don't know what to do about it. The cardinals and flying squirrels are happy to eat it though. If you're having a house sparrow, grackle, or cardinal problem call your local wild bird specialty store and see if they have it in, if they don't recommend that they consider carrying it.
Remember that if you are going to try a new seed that sometimes the birds don't take to it right away. It's like going to Wendy's for a #1 hamburger special. One day you get there and Wendy's is now a Taco Bell and the #1 special is now three tacos. It's not that you don't like tacos, but when you go there, you were expecting a hamburger. In time, you get over it and start having the taco special.
Labels: Bird Feeding
12 Comments:
Flying squirrels ?
You have flying squirrels in your garden ? Could you please post pictures ?
How silly of me to have never thought of giving the birds real nuts!! D'oh!! Now I wonder if the hazelnuts which come in my unsalted mixed nuts and which I really dislike are OK to maybe crunch up a bit and leave out for the birds? I usually pick them all out of my bag o' nuts but do keep them for serious mashing into my morning oatmeal. They seem more palatable when totally mushed.
Any ideas on if they're OK to feed birds.....maybe they'll turn their noses (?) up too.
Jacci in S.P.ME
Are they hull-less, as you seem to be saying? That would make me very cautious about using them. I have to be very careful about the hulled sunflower as it is so much more easily damaged by moisture. That is one reason that feeder is low capacity. I don't know that I could use a hull-less seed in my safflower feeder, which is an extra large one.
I also wonder, how does the price compare with plain old white safflower? I expect they charge a premium for being a fancy breed, but if it is hull-less that would add another still more to the price (while also making it worth more).
By the way, around here (Connecticut) safflower is a special favorite of Rose-breasted Grosbeaks when I am lucky enough to get them. And the titmice really love it.
I need a seed that finches won't eat but is loved by chickadees and nuthatches. Is there such a mythical seed?
And I just found a new use for safflower seeds. (I hope the URL does not truncate or wrap.)
http://www.smartcatbox.com/index.asp?PageAction=VIEWPROD&ProdID=16
And this appears to be a link to the main site for the new stuff.
http://www.safflowertech.com/nutrasaff.htm
I have flying squirrels but they are nocturnal. I have a pic of one at our tube feeder at night if someone wants to see it. They look like flying paper towels when you see them at night jumping through the trees.
As for excluding certain types of birds....don't they all have to eat??
We have many feeders and all birds are welcome all the time. I don't try to pick and choose.
I have a really spiffy bird feeder that I just adore but if I fill it with any type of seed other than safflower, the gray squirrels eat out of it. Do you think if I replace the safflower w/ golden safflower the squirrels will go for it again? I hope not because I fill my squirrel-proof feeders w/ black oil sunflower seeds, but I'd like to keep the other feeder as well.
Non-germinating safflower? Is it a GMO? If so, find out about the residual pesticide content before you feed it to any birds.
It might not be even any good for cat litter, as cats don't tolerate pesticide residues (or essential oils) at all.
Golden Safflower, also known as Nutrasaff, was developed through selective breeding and is not a GMO.
This seed does have a hull though it is greatly reduced. From what I have read one of the reasons this trait was selectively bred for was to make it easier for livestock to digest. I currently have some "planted" to see if any germination occurs.
We have had mixed results with our birds as of yet but it may be too early to tell if the birds' reactions is to the change of seed or the actual product itself. My own birds also showed hesitance when I switched to an all safflower feeder (traditional safflower). Picky buggers.
Word of warning: Do not use Pennington Wild Bird Seed. It contains milo, one of milo's varieties is Johnson Grass, which is included in this seed. This is a nasty, coarse, invasive perennial grass, which is almost impossible to eliminate.
Very cool blog. I've ordered the golden safflower from All Seasons Wild Bird Store (online). I will let you know if my birds like it. I've found that "my" Titmice love safflower seeds, but "my" Chickadees do not. I am hoping that the Chickadees will take to the Golden Safflower. Then I can move away from black oil sunflower seeds altogether, which attracts too many birds I don't like -- esp. those mean, loud Scrub Jays.
--Diane in N. California
Post a Comment
<< Home